Miranda Rights Don’t Apply for DUI Field Sobriety Tests

One of the most common frequently asked questions I get regarding Virginia DUI / DWI cases has to do with Miranda rights. We’ve talked about what the Miranda rights are, and I have a video coming out about Miranda rights in a DUI case.

Here’s a twist that I haven’t discussed: My prior discussions have focused on the fact that you’re not in custody during a DUI investigation, so Miranda doesn’t apply. By the time you ARE in custody, the officer likely has all the evidence he needs to take you for a breath / blood test.

But what if you’re arrested for something other than DUI and THEN the officer becomes suspicious about DUI? That happened in the Gibson v. Commonwealth case.

In that case, the officer stopped Gibson and determined he was driving on a revoked license. The officer arrested Gibson and put him into the back of his cruiser.

While working on the paperwork, the officer smelled alcohol and became suspicious about whether or not Gibson was intoxicated. The officer took Gibson out and had him perform field sobriety tests (FSTs). But he had NOT given any Miranda warnings. The defense argued that the FSTs should be kept out of evidence.

The Court of Appeals ruled that FSTs aren’t “testimonial communication” within the meaning of the Fifth Amendment. The FSTs came into evidence. No Miranda was required.

Does that make sense to you? Probably not. Honestly, these distinctions are insane. The courts parse things very carefully and come up with rules that sometimes don’t make sense. But that’s all the more reason to consult with an attorney.

Photo by Howdy, I’m H. Michael Karshis

Andrew Flusche

My name is Andrew Flusche. I am a traffic and misdemeanor defense lawyer in Virginia. I limit my practice to traffic tickets and misdemeanor defense, so I know the ins and outs of these offenses. I literally wrote the book on reckless driving in Virginia which you can get on Amazon here or download for free here. I opened my practice in 2008 after earning my Juris Doctor degree from the University of Virginia School of Law. Since then, I have earned over 600 5-star reviews from happy clients on Google, Yelp, and Facebook. If you’ve been charged with a misdemeanor offense in Virginia, please don’t hesitate to contact me. Your initial consultation is always free, and you'll talk directly with me about the details of your case.

What's Next?

Get Free Answers

I wrote the book on reckless driving. It’s the most-reviewed Virginia reckless driving resource on Amazon.com.

Get Your Free Copy

I wrote the book on DWI. It’s jam-packed full of answers for your case.

Get Your Free Copy

My special report about driving on suspended explains six critical issues to possibly fight in your case.

Get Your Free Copy

I wrote the book on reckless driving. It’s the most-reviewed Virginia reckless driving resource on Amazon.com.

Get Your Free Copy

I wrote the book on DWI. It’s jam-packed full of answers for your case.

Get Your Free Copy

My special report about driving on suspended explains six critical issues to possibly fight in your case.

Get Your Free Copy

CONTACT ME TODAY

I provide free consultations for traffic tickets and misdemeanors in my area. If I can't help, I'll do my best to connect you with someone who can.

540.318.5824

andrew@andrewflusche.com

Contact Andrew